Holiday gift guides for the table, kitchen and host →
Bonwits

Thanksgiving Table Essentials: Six Things to Own

Thanksgiving is the one dinner a year that asks for real equipment. Six things, bought once, that make the day calmer and the table better.

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It never decides what we recommend. How we are funded

Our top picks

6 picks, each linked to the exact listing
  1. 1ThermoWorks DOT Alarm Thermometer, Dove GreyCheck priceAmazon
  2. 2Villeroy & Boch For Me Oval Platter, 16 in, WhiteCheck priceAmazon
  3. 3Wüsthof Classic 2-Piece Carving SetCheck priceAmazon
  4. 4Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Gravy Boat, OysterCheck priceAmazon
  5. 5Solino Home Cotton Linen Tablecloth White, Dru 60 x 120 inCheck priceAmazon
  6. 6Marquis By Waterford Treviso Candlestick PairCheck priceAmazon
The Thanksgiving table, set and served

Most of Thanksgiving is cooking, and most of the stress comes from the parts around it: a turkey on a platter too small, a carving knife that tears, gravy in a measuring jug, a table that looks like a weeknight. None of it is hard to fix, and none of it needs replacing next year.

The six things below cover the day from the oven to the table. A leave-in thermometer that tells you when the bird is done. A platter that holds it. A carving set that slices it cleanly. A gravy boat that keeps the gravy warm, a tablecloth sized for a long table, and a pair of candlesticks for when the lights go down.

Everything here is sold on Amazon by Amazon.com or the maker, and most of it will get used well beyond one Thursday in November. Order by early November; the week before the holiday is when stock runs thin.

How we chose

  1. Does the job on the day. Each piece solves a specific Thanksgiving problem, from knowing when the turkey is done to keeping the gravy warm.
  2. Used the rest of the year. A platter for every roast, a thermometer for every loaf, candlesticks for every dinner party.
  3. Plain enough to match. White porcelain, white linen, clear crystal and steel, which sit with any dishes you already own.
  4. Sold on Amazon by the maker or Amazon.com. No third-party resellers, so what arrives is what the maker intends.

We read makers’ specifications, warranties, care instructions and the sources listed at the end. We do not accept paid placements. How we choose

The 6 picks, in detail

ThermoWorks DOT Alarm Thermometer, Dove Grey

Best overallNo. 1

ThermoWorks DOT Alarm Thermometer, Dove Grey

Our take. A probe that stays in the turkey and an alarm that sounds when it is done, which is the whole trick of a juicy bird.

Keeps for
Years; the probe is replaceable
Type
Leave-in probe with target alarm
Range
-58 to 572°F
Display
Large, backlit, current and target temperatures
Mounting
Magnetic back, kickstand
Housing
IP65 splash resistant

The DOT is ThermoWorks' simplest leave-in thermometer. The probe goes into the thickest part of the breast before the bird goes in the oven, the cable runs out through the door, and the unit sits on the counter or sticks to the oven with its magnet. Set the target with two buttons and it sounds an alarm when the meat gets there.

Most dry turkeys are overcooked turkeys, left in for another twenty minutes because nobody was sure. The USDA says turkey is safe at 165°F, checked in the thickest part of the breast, the innermost thigh and the wing. A leave-in probe tells you when the breast gets close without opening the oven again and again.

Pair it with a quick instant-read thermometer to check the thigh at the end. Skip it if you already own a leave-in probe you trust.

The catch. Only one probe, so it watches one spot; check the thigh separately before the bird comes out.

Villeroy & Boch For Me Oval Platter, 16 in, White

The platterNo. 2

Villeroy & Boch For Me Oval Platter, 16 in, White

Our take. A plain white German porcelain platter with a wide rim, big enough for a carved turkey and every roast after it.

Made in
Germany
Keeps for
Decades; the edge is made to resist chipping
Size
16 in oval
Material
Premium porcelain
Care
Dishwasher and microwave safe
Oven safe
Up to 392°F

Villeroy & Boch's For Me platter is 16 inches of white premium porcelain, made in Germany, with a wide rim that keeps juices off the tablecloth. The maker says the edges are shock and impact resistant, and it goes in the dishwasher, the microwave and the oven up to 392°F.

A 16 inch platter holds a carved turkey arranged in slices, with room for the legs and wings, and most households find carving in the kitchen and bringing the platter out easier than carving at the table. It is also the right size for a ham, a leg of lamb or a whole fish the rest of the year.

Skip it if you plan to present a large whole bird at the table before carving. For that you want 18 inches or more, and a platter that size is a storage problem the other 364 days.

The catch. Tight for a large whole turkey; it is a platter for a carved bird.

Wüsthof Classic 2-Piece Carving Set

The carving setNo. 3

Wüsthof Classic 2-Piece Carving Set

Our take. A forged German carving knife and fork that slice the breast into neat pieces instead of shreds.

Made in
Germany (Solingen)
Keeps for
Decades; limited lifetime warranty
Pieces
8 in hollow-edge carving knife, 6 in carving fork
Steel
High-carbon stainless, forged, 58 HRC
Handles
Full tang, triple riveted, synthetic
Warranty
Limited lifetime

Wüsthof has made knives in Solingen for more than 200 years, and the Classic is its best-selling line. This set is an 8 inch hollow-edge carving knife and a 6 inch carving fork, forged from a single block of high-carbon stainless steel, tempered to 58 HRC, with full-tang, triple-riveted handles.

A carving knife is long and narrow for a reason. It draws through a turkey breast in one stroke, and the hollow edge, the row of shallow scallops along the side, helps the slice fall away rather than stick to the blade. The fork holds the bird steady without shredding it.

Skip it if you have a good, sharp chef's knife and do not mind using it; it will do the job. Hand wash and dry both pieces, and they will last as long as the family.

The catch. About $240 for tools used a few times a year; a sharp chef's knife is a reasonable substitute.

Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Gravy Boat, Oyster

The gravy boatNo. 4

Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Gravy Boat, Oyster

Our take. A heavy stoneware gravy boat that holds its heat, in a soft grey that sits with white china.

Keeps for
Many years; the glaze resists chips and crazing
Material
Stoneware
Color
Oyster
Care
Dishwasher safe
Safe in
Freezer, oven, microwave, broiler

Gravy goes cold fast in a thin jug, and it goes cold faster at a long table. Le Creuset's Heritage gravy boat is thick stoneware, which holds heat well, and it can be warmed in the oven or microwave before the gravy goes in.

The glaze is nonporous and resists chips, scratches and stains, and the boat is safe in the freezer, oven, microwave, broiler and dishwasher. Oyster is a pale warm grey that goes with white dinnerware and does not shout Thanksgiving, so it comes out again at Christmas.

Skip it if you want a gravy boat that matches a formal china pattern; your china maker probably makes one. At about $38 it is otherwise the easiest item on the list.

The catch. Stoneware is heavy, and a full boat passed hand to hand along a long table is a two-handed job for some guests.

Solino Home Cotton Linen Tablecloth White, Dru 60 x 120 in

The tableclothNo. 5

Solino Home Cotton Linen Tablecloth White, Dru 60 x 120 in

Our take. A long white cotton and linen cloth that fits the table with both leaves in, and washes at home.

Keeps for
Years of holidays; machine washable
Size
60 x 120 in, seats 8 to 10
Fiber
75% cotton, 25% linen
Color
White
Care
Machine wash gentle, tumble dry low, warm iron

Thanksgiving is the one night the extension leaves come out, and most tablecloths are too short for it. Solino's Dru is 60 by 120 inches, which the maker recommends for tables seating eight to ten, and it hangs with a proper drop on a standard rectangular table at that length.

It is 75 percent cotton and 25 percent linen, so it has the matte, slightly textured look of linen but wrinkles less and costs about a third of Solino's pure linen cloths. It is machine washable on a gentle cycle; take it out promptly and iron it warm, or steam it on the table.

Measure first: table length plus about 16 to 24 inches gives a good drop at each end. Skip it if you want the weight and hand of pure linen; our tablecloth guide covers those.

The catch. White and gravy are old enemies; treat spills the same night.

Marquis By Waterford Treviso Candlestick Pair

The candlesticksNo. 6

Marquis By Waterford Treviso Candlestick Pair

Our take. A tall pair of clear crystal candlesticks that make the Thanksgiving table look like an occasion.

Keeps for
Generations, if not dropped
Set
Pair
Height
10 in
Material
Crystal
Care
Hand wash with a soft cloth
Packaging
Gift boxed

Candlelight does more for a holiday table than any centerpiece, and it has a practical side: tall candles light faces across the table without blocking anyone's view. The Treviso pair are 10 inch crystal candlesticks with an architectural profile, from Waterford's Marquis line, and they come gift boxed.

Clear crystal suits any dishes and any season, so the pair will come out for Christmas, birthdays and ordinary dinners long after the turkey. Use unscented white or ivory dinner candles; our candlesticks guide lists the ones worth buying.

Skip them if you prefer the warmth of brass or have small children at the table. Hand wash with a soft cloth only.

The catch. Crystal chips if knocked, and about $200 is a lot for a pair; any heavy, stable candlestick will do the job.

Compare the picks

PickBest forMade inKeeps forBuy
ThermoWorks DOT Alarm Thermometer, Dove GreyThermoWorks DOT Alarm Thermometer, Dove GreyBest overallNot statedYears; the probe is replaceableCheck priceAmazon
Villeroy & Boch For Me Oval Platter, 16 in, WhiteVilleroy & Boch For Me Oval Platter, 16 in, WhiteThe platterGermanyDecades; the edge is made to resist chippingCheck priceAmazon
Wüsthof Classic 2-Piece Carving SetWüsthof Classic 2-Piece Carving SetThe carving setGermany (Solingen)Decades; limited lifetime warrantyCheck priceAmazon
Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Gravy Boat, OysterLe Creuset Heritage Stoneware Gravy Boat, OysterThe gravy boatNot statedMany years; the glaze resists chips and crazingCheck priceAmazon
Solino Home Cotton Linen Tablecloth White, Dru 60 x 120 inSolino Home Cotton Linen Tablecloth White, Dru 60 x 120 inThe tableclothNot statedYears of holidays; machine washableCheck priceAmazon
Marquis By Waterford Treviso Candlestick PairMarquis By Waterford Treviso Candlestick PairThe candlesticksNot statedGenerations, if not droppedCheck priceAmazon

Compared.

Every comparison

A timeline for the table

The weekend before: wash and iron the tablecloth, count plates, glasses and flatware, and check that candles fit the candlesticks.

The night before: set the table completely. It is one less job on the day, and any missing piece is still easy to borrow.

On the day: warm the platter and gravy boat in a low oven while the turkey rests, and light the candles when the food comes out.

Carving in the kitchen

Let the turkey rest, loosely covered, while the gravy is finished. Remove the legs and wings, then take each breast off the bone whole and slice it across the grain. Arrange everything on the warmed platter. It is faster and neater than carving at the table, and nobody watches you struggle.

What to skip

Electric carving knives, novelty turkey platters, disposable foil roasters on the table, and scented candles anywhere near the food.

Frequently asked questions

What temperature should a turkey reach?

The USDA says 165°F, checked in the thickest part of the breast, the innermost part of the thigh and the wing. A leave-in probe tells you when you are close.

What size platter do I need for a turkey?

About 16 inches holds a carved turkey comfortably. To present a large whole bird at the table, you want 18 inches or more.

What size tablecloth fits a table for ten?

Usually 60 by 120 inches on a rectangular table. Measure the table and add 16 to 24 inches to the length and width for a good drop.

Do I need a carving set?

Not strictly. A long, sharp knife does the job. A carving set makes neater slices and holds the bird steady, and a good one lasts decades.

Should Thanksgiving candles be scented?

No. Scent competes with the food. Use unscented taper or dinner candles on the table.

Ready to buy

6 picks, each linked to the exact listing
  1. 1ThermoWorks DOT Alarm Thermometer, Dove GreyCheck priceAmazon
  2. 2Villeroy & Boch For Me Oval Platter, 16 in, WhiteCheck priceAmazon
  3. 3Wüsthof Classic 2-Piece Carving SetCheck priceAmazon
  4. 4Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Gravy Boat, OysterCheck priceAmazon
  5. 5Solino Home Cotton Linen Tablecloth White, Dru 60 x 120 inCheck priceAmazon
  6. 6Marquis By Waterford Treviso Candlestick PairCheck priceAmazon

Sources

  1. ThermoWorks, DOT
  2. USDA FSIS, Let's Talk Turkey Roasting
  3. Villeroy & Boch
  4. Wüsthof
  5. Le Creuset
  6. Solino Home

More in Hosting

See all →

The Bonwits Letter

One good email, on Sundays.

What is worth buying for the house this week, what is actually on sale, and what to skip. Short, and never sponsored.

Unsubscribe any time. We never share your address.